he Pentagon is constructing a computer system that
could create a vast electronic dragnet, searching for personal
information as part of the hunt for terrorists around the
globe — including the United States.
As the director of the effort, Vice Adm. John M.
Poindexter, has described the system in Pentagon documents and
in speeches, it will provide intelligence analysts and law
enforcement officials with instant access to information from
Internet mail and calling records to credit card and banking
transactions and travel documents, without a search
warrant.
Historically, military and intelligence agencies have not
been permitted to spy on Americans without extraordinary legal
authorization. But Admiral Poindexter, the former national
security adviser in the Reagan administration, has argued that
the government needs broad new powers to process, store and
mine billions of minute details of electronic life in the
United States.
Admiral Poindexter, who has described the plan in public
documents and speeches but declined to be interviewed, has
said that the government needs to "break down the stovepipes"
that separate commercial and government databases, allowing
teams of intelligence agency analysts to hunt for hidden
patterns of activity with powerful computers.
"We must become much more efficient and more clever in the
ways we find new sources of data, mine information from the
new and old, generate information, make it available for
analysis, convert it to knowledge, and create actionable
options," he said in a speech in California earlier this
year.
Admiral Poindexter quietly returned to the government in
January to take charge of the Office of Information Awareness
at the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, known as
Darpa. The office is responsible for developing new
surveillance technologies in the wake of the Sept. 11 attacks.
In order to deploy such a system, known as Total Information Awareness,
new legislation would be needed, some of which has been
proposed by the Bush administration in the Homeland Security
Act that is now before Congress. That legislation would amend
the Privacy Act of 1974, which was intended to limit what
government agencies could do with private information.
The possibility that the system might be deployed
domestically to let intelligence officials look into
commercial transactions worries civil liberties
proponents.
"This could be the perfect storm for civil liberties in
America," said Marc Rotenberg, director of the Electronic
Privacy Information Center in Washington "The vehicle is the
Homeland Security Act, the technology is Darpa and the agency
is the F.B.I. The outcome is a system of national surveillance
of the American public."
Secretary of Defense Donald H. Rumsfeld has been briefed on
the project by Admiral Poindexter and the two had a lunch to
discuss it, according to a Pentagon spokesman.
"As part of our development process, we hope to coordinate
with a variety of organizations, to include the law
enforcement community," a Pentagon spokeswoman said.
An F.B.I. official, who spoke on the condition that he not
be identified, said the bureau had had preliminary discussions
with the Pentagon about the project but that no final decision
had been made about what information the F.B.I. might add to
the system.
A spokesman for the White House Office of Homeland
Security, Gordon Johndroe, said officials in the office were
not familiar with the computer project and he declined to
discuss concerns raised by the project's critics without
knowing more about it.
He referred all questions to the Defense Department, where
officials said they could not address civil liberties concerns
because they too were not familiar enough with the
project.
Some members of a panel of computer scientists and policy
experts who were asked by the Pentagon to review the privacy
implications this summer said terrorists might find ways to
avoid detection and that the system might be easily
abused.
"A lot of my colleagues are uncomfortable about this and
worry about the potential uses that this technology might be
put, if not by this administration then by a future one," said
Barbara Simon, a computer scientist who is past president of
the Association of Computing Machinery. "Once you've got it in
place you can't control it."
Other technology policy experts dispute that assessment and
support Admiral Poindexter's position that linking of
databases is necessary to track potential enemies operating
inside the United States.
"They're conceptualizing the problem in the way we've
suggested it needs to be understood," said Philip Zelikow, a
historian who is executive director of the Markle Foundation
task force on National Security in the Information Age. "They
have a pretty good vision of the need to make the tradeoffs in
favor of more sharing and openness."
On Wednesday morning, the panel reported its findings to
Dr. Tony Tether, the director of the defense research agency,
urging development of technologies to protect privacy as well
as surveillance, according to several people who attended the
meeting.
If deployed, civil libertarians argue, the computer system
would rapidly bring a surveillance state. They assert that
potential terrorists would soon learn how to avoid detection
in any case.
The new system will rely on a set of computer-based pattern
recognition techniques known as "data mining," a set of
statistical techniques used by scientists as well as by
marketers searching for potential customers.
The system would permit a team of intelligence analysts to
gather and view information from databases, pursue links
between individuals and groups, respond to automatic alerts,
and share information efficiently, all from their individual
computers.
The project calls for the development of a prototype based
on test data that would be deployed at the Army Intelligence
and Security Command at Fort Belvoir, Va. Officials would not
say when the system would be put into operation.
The system is one of a number of projects now under way
inside the government to lash together both commercial and
government data to hunt for patterns of terrorist
activities.
"What we are doing is developing technologies and a
prototype system to revolutionize the ability of the United
States to detect, classify and identify foreign terrorists,
and decipher their plans, and thereby enable the U.S. to take
timely action to successfully pre-empt and defeat terrorist
acts," said Jan Walker, the spokeswoman for the defense
research agency.
Before taking the position at the Pentagon, Admiral
Poindexter, who was convicted in 1990 for his role in the
Iran-contra affair, had worked as a contractor on one of the
projects he now controls. Admiral Poindexter's conviction was
reversed in 1991 by a federal appeals court because he had
been granted immunity for his testimony before Congress about
the case.